Assignments:
(This post updated May 26 with guidance documents for arguments and negotiations.)
LESSON ONE
Introduction to American defamation and privacy torts, and offensive pleadings.
In advance of class:
- Read 2 Tortz ch. 15(A), pp. 451-453 (“Origin of ‘Media Torts’”), and ch. 15(C)(1), pp. 535-536 (“Invasion of Privacy: Framework and Rules,” before subpart (a)) (2025 ed.). Then look over the common law of defamation as described in the RED BOXES on pages 454-462 (ch. 15(B)), and the common law of invasion of privacy as described in the RED BOXES on pages 536-540 (ch. 15(C)). We will examine the red-box content more closely together in class, but it will help if you’re not seeing it for the first time.
o For our study, you may download only chapter 15 of Tortz volume 2 (2025 ed.):
✔ Here from Dropbox. A Dropbox account is not required. Look for "Continue without logging in."
✔ Or here from Google Drive. A Google account is required.
o Not required, but if you like, all "red-box" texts from volumes 1 and 2 of Tortz (2025 ed.) are compiled in a document you may download: Dropbox, Google Drive.
o Not required, but if you like, the entire book, volume 2 of Tortz (2025 ed., chs. 9-18), can be downloaded here at SSRN. An SSRN account may be required for download and is free to create.
o Not required, but if you like, the entire book, volume 1 of Tortz (2025 ed., chs. 1-8), also can be downloaded here at SSRN.
- Download the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure (FRCivP) (LexisNexis 2025-26). Read FRCivP 8, 9, and 10, on pp. 27-32.
Remember to bring a writing and sharing device to class! You will receive further case facts for simulation in class. We will draft pleadings and exchange work.
For your later reference, these items we may use in class, but you do not have to review them in advance.
- Candace Owens claims Emmanuel Macron’s wife is a man, 7News Austl. (July 24, 2025) (video).
- Brigitte Macron to show court ‘scientific proof’ she is a woman in lawsuit against Candace Owens, NBC News (Sept. 18, 2025).
- Brigitte Macron Wins Cyberbullying Case, Hill TV (Jan. 6, 2026).
- Attorney Nicholas J. Brooks, Macron v. Owens: Analyzing Candace Owens’s Motion to Dismiss (Jan. 17, 2026).
- Judge Andrea L. Rocanelli, Delaware Superior Court Self-Represented Litigant Packet (n.d.): Dropbox, Google Drive.
- Delaware Pattern Jury Instructions (2025 ed.): Dropbox, Google Drive.
- Amended Complaint, Macron v. Owens (Del. Super. Ct. filed Sept. 26, 2025): Dropbox, Google Drive.
- Form complaint (Pa.) (edited) (Word): Dropbox, Google Drive.
LESSON TWO
First Amendment defense, and defensive pleadings and motions.
Whichever day we double up, remember to prepare two lessons.
In advance of class:
- Watch the video assigned (and hyperlinked) in 2 Tortz ch. 15(B)(5)(a), p. 494 (“Sea Change: N.Y. Times v. Sullivan” Assignment, same as follows): N.Y. Times v. Sullivan Summary, Quimbee (July 12, 2017).
- Read 2 Tortz ch. 15(B)(5)(a), pp. 495-497 (Sea Change: Notes and Questions).
- Read St. Amant v. Thompson (U.S. 1964): Dropbox, Google Drive.
- Watch the four videos assigned (and hyperlinked) in 2 Tortz ch. 15(C)(1)(c), pp. 585-586 (“Bollea” Assignment, regarding Bollea v. Gawker (Fla. Cir. Ct. 2016), same as below):
o Hulk Hogan, Gawker’s Civil Trial Over Sex Tape Continues, ABC News (Mar. 18, 2016).
o Testimony Gets Explicit at Hulk Hogan-Gawker Trial, CBS News (Mar. 8, 2016).
o Hulk Hogan Awarded $115 Million in Gawker Sex Tape Lawsuit, ABC News (Mar. 19, 2016).
o How the Hulk Hogan Lawsuit Against Gawker Explains Litigation Finance, Bloomberg TV (Feb. 3, 2020).
- Read FRCivP 12 and 56, on pp. 35-39, and pp. 149-52.
For your later reference, these items we may use in class, but you do not have to review them in advance.
- Excerpt of Nobody Speak: Trial of the Free Press (2017). The documentary film is copyrighted, but available in its entirety from Netflix.
- Bill Maher Speculates Donald Trump Having Sex with Laura Loomer, TMZ (Sept. 14, 2024).
- Bill Maher pulls off big win in Laura Loomer lawsuit, KnowKnewz (Apr. 23, 2026).
- All documents in Loomer v. Maher (M.D. Fla. 2026) are available at CourtListener.
- Form answer (Pa.) (Word): Dropbox, Google Drive.
- Form motion to dismiss (Ill.) (Word): Dropbox, Google Drive.
- Form motion for summary judgment (Ill.) (Word): Dropbox, Google Drive.
LESSON THREE
Pretrial discovery.
In advance of class:
- Read 2 Tortz ch. 15(B)(5)(c), pp. 516-17, 525-535 (Reconsidering Sullivan (introduction only, omitting Berisha case); Problem: Greenberg v. Horizon; (Greenberg) Notes and Questions).
- Read FRCivP 26(b) and 34, at pp. 76-81, and pp. 106-109.
- Watch Five Tips to Prepare for Oral Argument, Harlan Institute (Oct. 4, 2024). Understand that we are studying motions practice in trial court, not appellate arguments, but the principles are the same.
LESSON FOUR
Motions arguments; other media torts.
In advance of class, prepare motions
arguments on assigned Case Studies. Here is a guidance document on skills and assessment for motions arguments:
Dropbox Google Drive
For your later reference, these items we may use in class, but you do not have to review them in advance.
- Jeffrey Wigand: The Big Tobacco whistleblower, 60 Minutes (Feb. 4, 1996).
- Excerpt of The Insider (1999). The film is copyrighted, but available in its entirety from Hulu.
- Google and Meta to pay millions in damages for user addiction in landmark lawsuit, BBC News (Mar. 25, 2026).
LESSON FIVE
Anti-SLAPP, pretrial settlement negotiation; and final examination.
In advance of class:
- Watch the Global Law Classroom, “Principled Negotiation as Successful Negotiation,” by Prof. Jennifer Stevenson (Willamette University).
- Prepare to negotiate the best possible outcome for your clients in assigned Case Studies. Key to negotiation is identifying the strengths and weaknesses of your client’s case, relative to the legal and practical issues we have covered.
- Here is a guidance document on skills and assessment for settlement negotiations:
Dropbox Google Drive
For your later reference, these items we may use in class, but you do not have to review them in advance.
- Uniform Law Commission, Public Expression Protection Act (2020).
- Directive (EU) 2024/1069 (Apr. 11, 2024).
- Décret n° 2026-337 (Apr. 30, 2026) (France).
- Despite lack of statute, anti-SLAPP blocks mining company suit as abuse of process in South Africa, The Savory Tort (Feb. 25, 2021).
- Media want anti-SLAPP security while ignoring real harm, and nobody wants to talk about tort dysfunction, The Savory Tort (Apr. 21, 2021).
- State high court simplifies anti-SLAPP, draws picture, The Savory Tort (Mar. 1, 2024).
- Trump’s Lawyer Paid Off Stormy Daniels Because He ‘Cares,’ Late Show with Stephen Colbert (Mar. 21, 2018).
- Trump taunts Stormy Daniels over tossed lawsuit, CNN (Oct. 16, 2018).
- Stormy Daniels ordered to pay Trump legal fees after court loss in defamation case, CBS News (Apr. 4, 2023).
- Donald Trump wins a decisive round in the Stormy Daniels trial, France 24 English (Nov. 23, 2024).
Final Examination
The exam may cover all assigned content and all in-class content. The exam probably will comprise a multiple-choice section and an essay section; details to be announced.
###